love, personal
Comments 12

bread & butter Vs death: the neuroscience of Arguing

relationships, online dating, raising a teenager, over 50, positive ageing

#1. You [with soft tone]: ‘Sorry I’m late for the movie, I thought you said it started at 7 not 6. And the traffic was terrible.’

Me: ‘ I feel pretty annoyed you’re so late, but I guess we can see the 8pm session, or just go home? Maybe we need to check in re the exact movie time on the actual day, so this doesn’t happen again?’

You: ‘I’m so sorry darlin, I felt really bad when I realised I was letting you down. Let’s see the 8pm, and I’ll buy the popcorn. Hug me for a moment first though.’

This is a ‘bread & butter’ misunderstanding and reaction (i.e. just an everyday disagreement). The exchange is clear: You made a genuine mistake, and have owned it, apologised, and given the injured party the power to decide what happens next. Both of you decided to reassure the other that they were still important and cared about, despite the mix-up. Plus long hugs are calming.

FullSizeRender (12)

#2. You [in brusque tone]: ‘Sorry I’m late for the movie, I thought you said it started at 7 not 6. And the traffic was terrible.’

Me: ‘This is the 4th time you’ve been late in a week. FFS, you always do this! I thought you were either dead in a car accident, or just being the worst partner ever.’

You: ‘God, calm down, you’re such an uptight drama queen. It’s only a film!”

Me: ‘I’m fuming. I don’t even want to see a film now; in fact, I don’t even wannna really see you anymore this evening!’

You: ‘Yeah, I’m not in the mood for crap like this either now! I’ll just text you in a couple of days; I don’t need this hassle.’

This has become a ‘fight/flight/freeze’ situation, not because the circumstances really warrant it, but because both parties have had their attachment systems triggered. That means that their deepest programmed survival instincts of avoiding Negativity (specifically abandonment and rejection) are surging through their bodies, in the form of adrenaline and cortisol. It’s an Argument. And biologically, it feels like a fight to the death.

The latest neuroscience research on how our bodies behave when we’re in love or fighting is fascinating; it’s easy to get obsessed researching this topic. There are practical articles, like this one for example: Neuroscience tips to remain calm in an argument HERE (Focus on the other person/don’t yell/keep body posture neutral/Breathe deep/exit the argument earlier rather than later).

Elsewhere there are clear principles to follow for resolving conflict:

  1. Show basic concern for the other’s well being
  2. Maintain focus on the specific problem at hand
  3. Refrain from generalizing the conflict
  4. Be willing to engage
  5. Effectively communicate feelings and needs

But NONE of this helped me when I was disagreeing with H last week HERE! I saw it unravelling before my eyes (we were Face-timing), and could feel my body getting stressed and elevated, but it just happened so fast… Plus, I could see it was happening to both of us… We were losing our playful, sweet, creative Snail & Crab connection…


Upcycled postcard by H  ©bone&silver

In adult relationships and arguments, as soon as one or other of you ‘flips your lid’, you’ve lost access to the pre-frontal cortex of your brain, which controls the limbic system. This means you are literally flooded with adrenaline (causing the fight/flight/freeze sensation I mentioned before), while all capacity for compassion, mindfulness, and kindness to Self & Other flies out the window.

All we can do is practise our awareness (easier written than done when discussing chores vs social life with a teenager who goes from 2/10 reactions to 10/10 in a microsecond for example). But ask yourself how your parents fought, and how you fought with each of them?

For most of us, it’s a blend of voice raising, sulking, removal of privileges, or delayed discussions once everything’s calmed down. Other people were yelled at, insulted, shoved or even hit. Some mothers withdrew, while others wept. Some parents drank, threw furniture, or seethed in silent white fury; others were basically absent, either emotionally or literally. The full spectrum happens, and it all has a profound effect on how we disagree & argue.

It’s worth remembering too that we have an inbuilt survival bias toward the negative: typically it takes 5-10 positive interactions to overcome 1 negative one. So every fight with your caregiver (when young), or beloved (when older), can create a deeply unsettling state of arousal (and I don’t mean the good, sexy kind).

I felt ‘H’ and I tiptoeing back towards our ‘togetherness’ slowly HERE. We texted, emailed, and talked on the phone. A long, quiet hug would have been AWESOME. Nothing like it for calming the nervous system [5 more sleeps till we get one!].

Long-distance dating can be tough, but I’d rather share my bread & butter with H than anyone else, and we simply have to practise all the other less fun stuff too.


Thanks H x


How you respond to the issue… is the issue. Frankie Perez




  1. Simone says

    Thanks for this. Happens to me – even with awareness. Looking st it being less intense & lessfrequent & less if a thing each time. Hugs are good

    Liked by 1 person

    • I hope this helps- we all just need to keep practicing & breathing & hugging… I can’t believe it’s so hard!
      Thanks for reading & commenting- good luck 👍🏼❤


    • Oh Honey, living together + kids is never gonna be a smooth path… arguments are guaranteed- it’s the making up & reassuring that’s most important. Thanks as ever for reading & commenting xxx ❤


  2. Awesome tips! I’ll be referring back to these often. I feel like I lose all sense of logic when I become angry, and I am quick to blame. I hate it! I think the most valuable tip for me is going to be to “focus on the other person”.

    Liked by 1 person

    • thanks again- I honestly think this is one of the best posts I’ve written- we absolutely lose our logic when we fight- it’s SO HARD to just breathe, pause, & yes, focus on the Other xx

      Liked by 1 person

      • It is so hard! I need lots of practice with this.

        I’ve noticed that I’m in a weird dysfunctional patterns with certain family members and with Mars. Sometimes I’m snappy and horrible for no reason other than I learned to react that way long ago even though there’s no longer any reason for me to act like that now (i.e. there’s no longer any animosity). And even realizing that I do it hasn’t helped… yet.

        Liked by 1 person

        • Me too with family members! 😖
          Sometimes I realize I’m sounding like my Dad used to, when he was grumpy… And he sounded a bit like his Dad when he was grumpy… you can see where I’m going with this can’t you? All we can do is keep trying to be Present, & keep breathing, trying to be kind & compassionate… so easier said (or written) than done 🙏🏼

          Liked by 1 person

  3. My husband and I have learnt a lot about healthy ways to disagree over the years. I love this post (not because you argued because that makes me sad) but because of the science behind it. Thank you for sharing and I hope you got your hug

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks for commenting- I love hearing that married couples fight & learn & practice healthier ways; it seems like that’s the best we can do. I had to wait a week for my hug because of the distance, but I’ve got it now : )

      Liked by 1 person

  4. What an awesome post! Very insightful into the nature of our biological tendencies. As humans, we most definitely need work on our awareness and self-control, although our emotional control is rather limited.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes indeed. I’m glad you enjoyed this post; I think it’s one of the ones I’m most proud of! I do need to write another about the neuroscience of being in love… I’ll get there soon hopefully 😊

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s